Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Oil filter differences

This is an awesome post about the difference in oil filters... don't believe the marketing on the boxes.
http://www.tacomaworld.com/forum/technical-chat/123608-toyota-oil-filter-made-thailand-vs-competition.html

What do you get for your money? Fram is a cheap filter.....The extra gaurd is $3.54 at Wallyworld (out here), while the Tough Gaurd is $5.96. Meanwhile....The over the counter Toyota Filter, Made in Thialand, is about $3.99. Words like "Extra Guard", or "Tough Gaurd" lead you to think your getting better protection for your engine. Right? I mean......Fram SAYS so! Hell.....The "Extra Guard" says right on the box, that it gives 3x's the protection, and the "Tough Gaurd" gives 6x's the protection....6 TIMES!  They use (according to the box) "Cellulose and Glass blended media" for the Extra Guard, while the Tough Gard uses "Intertwined Synthetic Glass and Cellulose Media". Sounds like good shit to me! What does the Toyota filter use? It doesnt say anything on the box...Right? Its gotta be a basic bottom line filter. What kinda filter can you possably get for 4 bucks? "I'll spend the extra cahs, and get a better filter".....WHOA!!!

Lets see what the differences are!
I bought 3 filters off the shelf, and decided to see for myself. I didnt get the lowest line filter, as...well.....who cares about those. And I didnt get th eK&N, or Mobil 1 as I didnt have enough cash. SO......On with the comparo.

These are the ones I compared:

Click for full-size image (888 x 592)


As you can see, The Toyota filter is taller than the Fram filters....

Click for full-size image (971 x 647)


And the Toyota filter is sealed, and pre lubbed:

Click for full-size image (886 x 591)



And for a short Video Comparo....







I measured the amount of filtering media the 2 Fram filters had, and they both have 115.9 sq. inches of media, while the Toyota filter has 225.9 sq. inches of media. Almost TWICE the amount as the 2 Frams.

More filters with special thanks to KenpachiZaraki for sending them to me to add to this 

The new ones added, are the STP, Bosch, K&N, and Mobil 1 filters.

Click for full-size image (959 x 639)


As you can see, THe Toyota filter is taller than the others, with the STP filter being the shortest.
STP part # S3614:
At $3.59 the STP filter is tied with the Fram EG3614 as the cheapest filter. When flipping the filter over, and looking at the underside, you can see the filter media, as there is no steel core as the others have. Instead, STP uses a rign type support, made of plastic. STP claims 96% efficiency, and 20% more dirt holding capacity over the "Nationally advertised brand". They are also the only filter to have listed on the side of the carton to change the oil and filter every 3000 miles.
It has 108 sq. inches of filtering media.




Bosch part #3330:
At $6.49, this filter is close in price to the Fram TG3614. The package claims it to be a "Premium Filter", and remove 99.9% of "Engine oil impurities". It also claims 42% more filtering media, and 30% thicker media than "conventional" filters. I could tell no difference in the thickness of the media than the other filters tested. It has 124.9 sq. inches of filter media.



K&N part # HP-1002:

At $13.99, this is the most expensive filter in the comparo. It boasts a Pre lubed gasket, yet the picture instruction say to oil it before installing. It has a 1" nut on the top of the filter, and claims "removal of 99% of harmfull contaminants". It has 103.6 sq. inches of filtering media.



Mobil 1 part # M1-102:

At $12.99, this filter is on the higher end of the price range. The package claims the gasket is pre lubricated, though it clearly is not. The picture instructions also say to oil the gasket before installing. On the carton, it claims to have a "multi pass" efficiency of 99.2% vs. 94% for the "leading brand". It has 103.6 sq. inches of filtering media.



The K&N and Mobil 1 are virtually identical internally as you can get. Even the bases look the same, and are stamped with the same "AA".


Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)



Oil Filter OEM OF 1004:
This filter was provided by RidingonTRD (Rich)
Its made in China, is about the same size as the Toyota filter, and has 134.2 sq. in. of filtering media. THe media is a basic paper type. The end is sealed in plastic, but not pre lubed.

Click for full-size image (952 x 635)


Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)


Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)




The main concern I have, is the center tube, although perforated, the holes are very small. I think this would cause oil pressure to be a bit higher, and not flow the volume needed for propper lubrication.

Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)



Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)


Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)




I cant find a price online for this filter.

MANN Filter ML 1003:
This filter was provided by one of our New Members, SRD (Steve)
Its made in the USA, and sells for about $2.99
Its about 2/3" shorter in height than the Toyota 90915-YZZD3
The filter media is paper, and has 121 sq. in. of surface area.

Click for full-size image (1017 x 678)


Click for full-size image (979 x 653)




Upon dissasembly, I noticed there is some black stuff on teh top of the fitler end cap, that easilly fell away with light pressure of my finger.
Also, The Bypss valve is made of cardboard, and did not seal well at all. The gap between the bypass valve, and the housing easilly allowed light to be seen in between. This will allow a percentage of un filtered oil to flow back into the engine. Also something interesting....The paper filtering media would begin to fall apart when rubbed lightly with my finger.

Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)


Pic of the Bypass valve:

Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)


Center tube:

Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)





Purolator PL10241:
Retail price is $5.79
Filter is Made in USA.

As you can see, this filter is a bit smaller than the OEM Toyota filter:
Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)


This filter is rated at 99.9% Efficency. On the package, It advertises its ability to hold 13 grams of contaminants, and then lets you know that that equates to 8 nails, 13 nuts, or 31 paper clips. It claims to use "Micronic media", but in reality, its just cheap paper media. It brags about its textured surface, and while I think this is cool, I would rather the filter media be where the money is spent when making a filter. There is 131.2 sq. in. of filter media. The baypass valve is a simple metal disk, and it does not seal against the top cap of the filter. The gasket is pre lubed with a teflon coating.

Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)






Wix 51348:
Retail price $3.99
Made in USA

This filter has 115 sq. in. of paper filtering media. The bypass valve is very well done, and seals nicely. As you can see, this filter is also much smaller than the OEM Toyota filter, with about half of the filtering media. Wix advertises this media as "Advanced" media. At an overall height of 3.5", the media takes up only 2" of height inside the housing.

Click for full-size image (947 x 631)


Click for full-size image (1000 x 667)





















Amsoil Ea15K51:
Retail price of $14.95
Made in USA

This filter is very much like the Wix, except for the filter media is a synthetic, with a unique mesh backing. With only 66 sq. in. of media, this is the least amount in a filter I have seen yet. Much like the Wix, only 2" of space inside the housing is used for media. Amsoil claims 98.7% efficiency when filtering down to 15 microns. They also claim its is guaranteed up to 15,000 miles. Against what, they dont say. The anti drain valve, and housing have the same part numbers, and manufacture as the Wix, which leads me to belive they are made in the same factory.


Click for full-size image (941 x 627)



Here is a pic of the mesh backing:

Click for full-size image (843 x 562)


And compared to the Wix:

Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)



Wix and Amsoil base plates:

Click for full-size image (967 x 645)


Click for full-size image (940 x 627)






Royal Purple 10-2835
Retail price $14.95
Made in USA

At 56.25 sq.- in. of filtering media, this is the least amount of filter media in a filter (in OEM replacement apps) thus far. Despite this, RP claims this filter will support extended oil change interrvals, up to 12k miles. The media IS 100% synthetic, with a wire mesh backing. RP also claims the anti drian back valve is "High performance", and it IS a cool Purple color......so....take that for what its worth. They also claim the filter housing is "Ultra Strength", and I will attest that this filter was THE hardest filter to destroy. Again.....take that for what its worth. I dont know of any Fram filters (despite them being absolute garbage) blowing apart under the hood. Anyway, construction is much like the Amsoil, but there are no part numbers on the base, and other parts. Once again, it is much smaller than the Toyota OEM filter.


Click for full-size image (998 x 665)


Click for full-size image (1024 x 683)



Click for full-size image (934 x 623)













Attached Thumbnails
Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-oil-filter-comparo-001.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-oil-filter-comparo-002.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-oil-filter-comparo-003.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-toyota-filter-comparo-2-001.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-toyota-filter-comparo-2-002.jpg 

Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-toyota-filter-comparo-2-003.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-oem-oil-filter-001.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-oem-oil-filter-002.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-oem-oil-filter-003.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-oem-oil-filter-005.jpg 

Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-oem-oil-filter-006.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-oem-oil-filter-007.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-mann-oil-filter-comparo-001.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-mann-oil-filter-comparo-003.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-mann-oil-filter-comparo-005.jpg 

Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-mann-oil-filter-comparo-006.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-mann-oil-filter-comparo-007.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-purolator-filter-001.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-purolator-filter-002.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-filters-001.jpg 

Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-filters-002.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-filters-003.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-filters-004.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-filters-007.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-filters-008.jpg 

Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-filters-009.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-filters-010.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-royal-purple-001.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-royal-purple-002.jpg   Toyota Oil Filter (Made in Thailand) vs. the competition........-royal-purple-004.jpg  

No comments:

Post a Comment

Post a Comment